Chotai, the objective of this research is to investigate the failure analysis of the connecting rod of the automotive engine. Onan connecting rod failure of all the small engines that i have dealt with over the years i have found onans to be the the most sensitive to low oil levels. High factor of safety is provided as the failure of the connecting. Most downloaded engineering failure analysis articles elsevier. The lubrication channel exhibited an area containing an embedded wbased material. In general, the failure occurs at the big end of connecting rod. Possible causes of connecting rod distortion followed by edge wear. Shenoy and fatemi 2005 were explained about optimization study was performed on a steel forged connecting rod with a consideration. Here, the connecting rod is replaced by various materials like stainless steel, aluminium, c70 steel and also a design change by inducing truss member is suggested. The proposed design explores weight reduction opportunities for a production forged steel connecting rod.
Tension and compression analysis in reciprocating engine. Pdf failure analysis of a diesel generator connecting rod. Fem analysis of connecting rod of different materials using ansys. Connecting rods are widely used in variety of engines such as, opposepiston engines, vengines, opposed cylinder engines, radial engines and inline engines. The most downloaded articles from engineering failure analysis in the last 90 days. Figure 1 shows two sets of parts from the same engine. This thesis describes designing and analysis of connecting rod. In consideration to this, we present you with a list of possible causes of connecting rod failures and their possible prevention techniques. In this paper author had focused on analysis of the connecting rod failure. Check all connecting rod housing bores for taper, roundness and size, using a bore gauge or inside micrometer. Stress and failure analysis of the connecting rod of diesel. Check for parallelism between the large and small ends of rod. Instead, the connecting rod was supported against the axial push load at the rod end of crank pin bearing. But what causes the rods failure remains a mystery to many.
Tension and compression analysis in reciprocating engine connecting rods. Pdf in many cases, the major reason behind or causing catastrophic engine failure is the occurrence of the connectingrod failure and sometimes, such. Static stress analysis of connecting rod using finite element. Design and analysis of assembly of piston, connecting rod and. In this study the failure analysis of the connecting rod of turbocharged diesel engine was performed. When going over the failure path of this particular race engine you start at square 1. As seen, there is a hole in the upper, and lower block casing this right off the bat tells us we have a connecting rod failure of some type. In this particular instance, the connecting rod bearing spun, damaging the bearings, connecting rod and crankshaft. Failure and damage are also more in connecting rod, so stress analysis in connecting rod is very important. Therefore, the connecting rod should be able to withstand tremendous load and transmit a great deal of power smoothly. The study applied a finite element analysis and metallographic. Fatigue failure analysis of diesel engine connecting rod 2018280067 connecting rod of a high performance reciprocating internal combustion engine is.
Thus, the major aim of the current work is to analyze the connecting rod failure. Bearing surfaces which reveal scratches or trenches are typical of particle wear. Finally the paper is concluded and recommendations are proposed in section vi. A connecting rod can destroy a block in this manner from 3 different ways.
Most failures associated with the sucker rod form of artificial lifted wells using the sucker rod lift method can be attributed to. Piston damages case studies and possibilities of early detection jan filipczyk, zbigniew stanik. The connecting rods if not properly taken care of can result in engine damage. This is a situation where proper diagnosis is critical in preventing future problems. Obtained results showed that the stress concentration in crack origin was observed.
If the engine is stopped immediately after the pin breaks it might be possible to save the engine. The following failure analysis descriptions are written as a general cause of each listed symptom but dfc would like to remind our customers that an engine can fail as a result of not just any one of these descriptions but sometimes multiple causes. Throughout the course of this project, an idealized model of a connecting rod, piston, and flywheel will be modeled and analyzed. Method uses detailed analysis of plastic deformation at localized. Was the failure caused by detonation, overloading, oil breakdown or connecting rod failure. Root cause failure analysis of connecting rod big end bearing suspected cause for the failure from the previous analysis is operating temperature of the compressor and it consumes the radial internal clearance as well it deteriorates the lubricant life. The big end is connected to the bearing journal on the crank throw. Causes of failure with a connecting rod it still runs.
Pdf design, buckling and fatigue failure analysis of connecting. Failure analysis of a four cylinder diesel engine crankshaft made from nodular cast iron 23 70 ductile cast iron. Salleh6 in this paper author had focused on analysis of the connecting rod failure. For some engines this results in catastrophic engine failure the connecting rod goes through the engine block or the crankshaft is bentbut for some engines it just causes a dramatic loss of power. The connecting rod is under a lot of stress with every rotation.
Understanding how to identify failures and their contributing factors. Pdf design, buckling and fatigue failure analysis of. Accelerated wear may be caused by fine abrasives left in from extended oil change intervals not monitored by analysis. In fact, most failures continue with increasing frequency until the entire rod string must be pulled and replaced. A connecting rod works in variably complicated conditions, and is subjected to not only the pressure due to the connecting rod mechanism, but also due to the. If a bearing isnt set into place securely, lubrication will be insufficient and cause failure. In this study the failure and stress analysis of the connecting rod of turbocharged diesel engine was performed. Fatigue and structural analysis of connecting rods. May 04, 2017 follow us along as we delve into the world of most common piston failures and what to look for when inspecting your broken parts. In the 4stroke internal combustion maritime v12 diesel engine herein studied, there has been a frequent failure of crankshafts. Yield, fatigue and buckling characteristics are often used as evaluation indexes for the performance of engine connecting rods in. Practical root cause analysis of connecting rod bushing.
Bearing failures bent or twisted connecting rod appearance bent rods will exhibit heavy wear on diagonally opposite sides of each shell, typically in an edgeloaded pattern. Failure analysis was used to determine the root causes of the engine breakdown, with a special emphasis on the determination of the causes that led to the failure of the connecting rod. Stress analysis of connecting rod for weight reduction a. When a rod bearing falls, an analysis should be made to determine the cause. Select a bearing material with higher load capacity check. May 04, 2017 follow along as we explore most common rad failures and what to look for when inspecting broken parts. Failure of piston due to various thermal and mechanical stresses. In this study, detailed load analysis was performed on connecting rod, followed by finite element method in ansys medium. The notch effect caused local increase of the stress levels. Pdf this paper presents the results of a failure analysis investigation conducted in a connecting rod from a diesel engine used in the.
Achievable failure frequency reductions require accurate failure root cause analysis and the implementation of corrective action measures to prevent failure recurrence. Failure analysis of crankshafts used in maritime v12 diesel engines. If this pin snaps the connecting rod is no longer connected to the engine. A failure analysis investigation of a connecting rod was conducted. Stress and failure analysis of the connecting rod of. An interesting study of failure analysis of connecting rod cap and connecting bolts of the compressor was presented in study. Its behavior is affected by the fatigue phenomenon due to the reversible. After removing the engine from the test bench, a visual overview of the broken connecting rod, the engine parts and the assemblies, as well as the correctness. This is why the connecting rod is the most stressed part of an engine system. Failure analysis of a diesel generator connecting rod. Engine bearing failure analysis guide edge wear due to distorted connecting rod imperfect journal geometry cavitation erosion spinning of the bearing in the housing. Journal of asian scientific research failure analysis of a. Root cause failure analysis of connecting rod big end. The seven cases of failure of the crankshafts reported in the.
The connecting rod is the intermediate member between the piston and the crankshaft. Check main bearing bores for alignment, taper, roundness and size. This sole objective of this technical paper, is to investigate the failure analysis of the connecting rod of the automotive combustion engine. Failure analysis of connecting rod at big end scientific. The connecting rod cr is the main moving parts and an important. Some failures are the result of manufacturing defects, but it is a very small percentage compared to those which result from normal wear or customer neglect.
Connecting rod bigend bearings are precisioninsert bearings. Failure analysis of a special vehicle engine connecting rod. If the existing design shows the failure, then suggest the minimum design changes in. In order to understand the true impact the automobile has had on our society, we would have to. When the repetitive stresses are developed in the connecting rod it leads to fatigue phenomenon which can cause dangerous ruptures. Follow along as we explore most common rad failures and what to look for when inspecting broken parts. Home bearing wear analysis bearing wear analysis bearing failure analysis normal wear exhibits smooth finish. This paper presents the results of a failure analysis investigation conducted in a connecting rod from a diesel engine 18 v, fourstroke used in the generation of electrical energy. Section v illustrates and compares the results with existing design i. For probabilistic analysis, the fea model has to be set up parametrically so that it can change its dimensions in response to the three random input variables for pds calculation loops.
A failure investigation has been conducted on a diesel engine connecting rod. In addition, the failure of the connecting rod may also result from other factors, such as poor fabrication and lubrication processes 2. To determine the failure reason of the connecting rod the numerical analysis and material investigation were performed. Fatigue failures are progressive and begin as small stress cracks that grow under the action of cyclic stresses. The study has dealt with two parts which are dynamic load and quasidynamic stress analysis of the connecting rod, and second to optimize the weight and cost. When the repetitive stresses are developed in the connecting rod it leads to fatigue phenomenon which can cause dangerous ruptures and damage. The work has to find out the stresses at various points on the connecting rod and the portion, which is more susceptible to failure and optimization of connecting rod. Probabilistic analysis for resolving fatigue failures of the. Oil forced out of the crankcase had escaped through the gaps in the engine cowl and contaminated the windscreen. Fatigue analysis and determining if design of connecting rod is safe or not. Rod is subjected to continuous compressing loading. Cr, finite element analysis, light vehicle engine, stress.
Its primary function is to transmit the push and pull from the piston pin to the crank pin, thus converting the reciprocating motion of the piston into rotary motion of the crank. The fracture occurred at the small head of the connecting rod. Pdf failure analysis of a fractured connecting rod dr. The second reason of connecting rods failure could be to small fillet radius in the critical zone of connecting rod, near the bolt hole. Excessive idling can result in an oil film that can not support the load needed. Its behavior is affected by the fatigue phenomenon due to the reversible cyclic loadings. Another compressor of the same design with similar rod load has history of reliable operation applying practical root cause analysis and well known. Fatigue analysis of connecting rod in ansys youtube. Root cause failure analysis rcfa is essential for failure frequency reduction in wells with artificial lift.
Twisted rods will exhibit wear running diagonally across the bearing surface. If an incorrect analysis is made, the repair may not remedy the original cause, and a repeat failure may occur. Yield, fatigue and buckling characteristics are often used as evaluation indexes for the performance of engine connecting rods in mass reduction design to optimize vibration. Bearing wear analysis bearing failure analysis normal wear exhibits smooth finish. Engine bearing function failure symptoms causes and. Causes of failure with a connecting rod corin tucker band. Dynamic analysis of the connecting rod is done by ram bansal 6. To evaluate the magnitude and location stresses in the existing connecting rod. All production personnel should have adequate knowledge and training in failure root cause analysis.
Failures of engine bearings and their prevention substech. Fatigue failure analysis of diesel engine connecting rod. Design and analysis of connecting rod using forged steel. Common piston failures and what to look for when inspecting. Analysis of connecting rod under different loading. Visual examination of the fracture showed that beach marks, typical for the fatigue. Design, buckling and fatigue failure analysis of connecting rod. Accelerated wear may be caused by fine abrasives left in from extended oil change. The results can be used for optimization for weight reduction and for design modification of the connecting rod.
When something goes wrong in your diesel engine, you want to get it fixed and get back on the road right away. If the engine is operating, connecting rod fails, this could cause a critical situation. Fatigue analysis of connecting rod using finite element analysis 789 the stress at any point on the connecting rod at this axial load can be interpolated from the axial stress analysis results. Design, buckling and fatigue failure analysis of connecting. When a connecting rod or main bearing cap is installed in the wrong position. When the repetitive stresses are developed in the connecting rod it leads to. Fragments of the no 4 connecting rod bearing cap were ejected through the hole and were found lying on the cooling baffles between the cylinders.
Then the cause can be eliminated so that the failure will not repeated. Connecting rod is designed by machine design approach and compared with the actual production drawing. Failure analysis of crankshafts used in maritime v12. The origin of the fracture was located at the conrod lubrication channel. Failure analysis of a four cylinder diesel engine crankshaft. The studies are been carried out by using finite element analysis and metallographic. Failure analysis of a diesel generator connecting rod sciencedirect.
Distorted bent or twisted connecting rod is one of the causes of localized loading of engine bearings resulting in excessive wear of the bearing surface along the bearing edge. Based on which the high strength carbon fiber connecting rod will be compared with connecting rod made up of stainless steel and aluminum alloy. Fatigue on engine pistons a compendium of case studies, engineering failure analysis. Failure analysis of connecting rod at big end core. Wbased material acted as nucleation site for cracks that propagated by fatigue. You must be able to distinguish the difference to know if a failure qualifies for warranty consideration. Mae 322 machine design lecture 5 fatigue mercer university. This paper presents the results of a failure analysis investigation conducted in a connecting rod from a diesel engine used in the generation of electrical energy. Pdf failure analysis of a fractured connecting rod. A connecting rod works in variably complicated conditions, and is subjected to not only the pressure due to the connecting rod mechanism, but also due to the inertia forces.
But simply saying that isnt enough to fully understand the dynamics of the situation. Mohammed et al 1 describe the cause of failure of connecting rod by finite element analysis with help of msc patran software and also performed the metallographic study of buckled connected rod. Connecting rod is part of an internal combustion engine that forms a link between the piston and the crankshaft 3, 4. It is no surprise that a failure in a connecting rod can be one of the most costly and damaging failures in an engine. However, it can be replaced, if the rod, crankpin, and other engine components are in good condition. When analyzing an engine failure all clearances, condition of components, operation and service of the vehicle must be taken into consideration.
The analysis clearly indicated the failure location at the thread root of the connecting rod, caused by improper screw thread profile. Sometimes its tempting to do the quickest or least expensive fix just to get going again. Fatigue analysis of connecting rod using finite element. Engine failure analysis mechanical advantage racing. Incorrect clearances will result in seizure of the connecting rod bearing. Catastrophic connecting rod failure can be as a result of incorrect clearances causing bearing failure, incorrect torque applied to the fasteners, engine over speeding resulting in hyperarticulation of the connecting rods and connecting rod bolt failure. I tore down the b48 that was on my 448 after it blew and found the crankshaft seal under the flywheel had a portion of the lip rolled up and leaking oil. Here we discuss the fatigue analysis of connecting rod. Since the piston is the main reciprocating part of an engine. Visual and scanning electron microscopy observations show that a lot of axial grooves appear on the internal surface close to the fracture and the fatigue cracks initiated from the axial grooves. The stresses associated with this failure have a maximum value that is typically less than the yield strength of the sucker rod steel in the.
633 575 1390 734 1370 1407 746 118 518 1352 1292 855 1049 1488 394 1385 410 1261 1237 26 1464 856 254 1067 484 286 1150 169 1388 888 1014 1208 179 496 962 806 184 1247